Wal-Mart’s Earnings Miss Likely to Entice Short Sellers
Posted by Brooks McFeely on Wed, Nov 12, 2008 @ 09:15 AM
The doom and gloom crowd has had a hard time cracking shares
of Wal-Mart (WMT) this year despite unprecedented economic and market turmoil. Unbelievably,
the stock is up over 27 percent in the past 12 months including an impressive
15.5% rise year-to-date. Compare that to a 28% drop in Target Corp. (TGT) shares
in 2008 and you’ll begin to see why shareholders have been rejoicing.
I suggest you hold your applause until after the earnings
release in tomorrow’s pre-market. The company is slated to report its Q3
results ahead of the opening bell on Thursday, Nov. 13th. Analysts
polled by Thomson Financial expect the mega-retailer to post a profit of $0.76
per share on revenue of $98.41 billion.
In looking back at the last five quarters, WMT shares have demonstrated a
rather lethargic reaction to its recent tendency to beat quarterly earnings expectations
and guide in-line. The most recent quarter in which guidance was below expectations
goes back all the way to August, 2007. Yes, this is before the credit storm hit
our global shores and while investors languished on the beaches of equity
exposure without so much as a passing thought of the risk of overexposure. Attention
Wal-Mart shoppers, shares on sale in isle 4!
As you can see by WMT’s earnings history, guidance is key to
how investors price in results. With
shares currently priced for perfection, a sharp shift in sentiment could emerge
should guidance show even the slightest weakness. The short crowd is drooling
here with short interest increasing over 8% in the last 30 days.
On Aug. 14, 2008, WMT slipped 0.4% in pre-market trade after
beating expectations and setting guidance in line with estimates. It turned
just slightly into the green in the following regular session, ending up 0.3%.
On May 13, 2008, WMT declined 1.2% in pre-market trade despite beating Q1
expectations and setting guidance in line for its Q2. It headed further south
in that day's regular session, losing 2.3% by the closing bell.
On Feb. 19, 2008, WMT gained 1.3% in pre-bell action after topping earnings
expectations and setting in-line guidance. It saw much of that early gain
evaporate in the regular session, ending the day up a mere 0.4%.
On Nov. 13, 2007, WMT advanced 3.6% in pre-market trade after topping Q3
estimates and setting Q4 guidance in line and FY EPS above forecasts. The stock
continued heading higher into the Nov. 13 regular session, ending the day up
6.1%.
On Aug. 14, 2007, WMT declined 4.3% in pre-bell action after it missed Q2
expectations and offered EPS guidance below the Street view. It continued
heading south in that day's regular session, closing bell-to-bell trade off 5%.
Times have changed and one might reasonably argue that the near
future for all retailers is less than chipper. Is Wal-Mart too big to fail? Of course,
and so is Circuit City (CC).